Products You May Like
Eli Roth’s 2023 Thanksgiving brings a neglected holiday to the genre. Typically horror movies circulating around the holidays pay tribute to slashing Santas and deranged cupids. This is something Roth decided a long time ago needed to change.
While the movie is full of campy fun, Roth’s upbringing inspired a take on the story that not just anyone could have wrangled into the script. In a very real way, the film is a tribute to Southern New England’s celebration of Turkey Day.

The Hostel creator grew up just west of Boston in Newton, Massachusetts. Thanksgiving is ripe with references, dialogue, and a twisted sense of praise for his roots. As someone who grew up just an hour from the pilgrim state, I can say his portrayal is spot on. Sure, he dialed the absurdity up to 11, but the homage he pays to Massachusetts rings true to us Yankees.
A Thanksgiving Tale
Childhood friends Eli Roth and writer Jeff Rendell first developed the idea for Thanksgiving at just 12 years old. The boys realized every other major holiday had at least one slasher film dedicated to it. A horror based on Turkey Day was long overdue. However, the movie didn’t officially begin to take form until 2007.

In adulthood the concept for Thanksgiving was further developed into a fake trailer. The preview of the non-existent upcoming film was to precede with others before the 2007 Grindhouse double feature; Planet Terror and Death Proof. The other faux trailers to accompany Thanksgiving included Machete, Don’t, Hobo with a Shotgun, and Werewolf Women of the S.S.
The faux trailer featured a masked killer carving his way through the residents of Plymouth, Massachusetts during their Thanksgiving festivities. Ridiculous moments include the head of a turkey mascot in the parade being decapitated. A cheerleader who has gone commando jumps on a trampoline, landing her split onto an erect knife blade. Finally, in a memorable last scene of the trailer a dinner features the body of a deceased woman. She is bound, roasted, and dressed as the traditional bird… including being stuffed to the brim inside her body cavities.
The audience response was beyond anything Roth and Rendell could have imagined. The enthusiastic fans demanded a full length feature film made off of the trailer. Not only did fans rave over the idea of a movie, their demand for the film persisted for years. The tenacity of the fans was so strong that Roth and Rendell finally obliged and delivered. In 2023 a fully finished Thanksgiving movie was delivered to fans on a silver platter.
A Love for the Region
The authenticity of Roth and co-writer Jeff Rendell’s New England heritage is seen throughout the film. For instance, the regional cadence embraced in the script bleeds onto the pages. Words such as “wicked”, “frappe”, and “jimmies” are all scripted into the dialogue.
The characters also embraced New England’s use of non-rhotic speaking. This is where the pronunciation of the “r” is dropped when followed by vowels with a “h”. The most notable example is “Pahk the cah in Hahvahd yahd”. An example for the Jaws fans is; “They’re in the yahd, not too fah from the cah”.
Additionally, it is with no shame that New Englander’s love dropping the F-bomb. In fact, it is the word that cements many of our thoughts together. Movieguide recorded the word being mentioned over 130 times. IMDB Parent’s Guide recorded the total to be 235! Whatever the official number is, Eli Roth certainly captured the essence of the Masshole.
Thankful for the Right Cast
Not only did the script reflect Roth’s homestate, the director also found the right actors to portray his vision.
Patrick Dempsey (Scream 3) is an addition to the cast that had many horror fans scratching their heads about. The actor is primarily known for his roles in romantic comedies, not campy slashers. However, his portrayal as Plymouth’s Sheriff Newlon fits seamlessly into the film. In the role Dempsey was able to embrace his Maine heritage, and by association his New England accent. Never before in his career was he able to speak unfiltered. In fact, early in his career the actor made a conscious effort to suppress his local dialect.

Dempsey wasn’t the only cast member who was able to revel in their natural New England accent. Actress Amanda Baker, a real life South Shore local, portrayed hot tempered and colorfully spoken diner waitress Lizzie. Her dialogue carried much of the regional authenticity and color. Baker also had some of the best lines in the movie, especially during the Black Friday riot;
“You know, you’re a fucking muppet! You Jim Henson motherfucker! Go back to Fraggle Rock!

Will there be Leftovers?
The ending of Thanksgiving was left wide open for a sequel.
In the wake of the fan’s rabid enthusiasm, Roth confirmed his work on a sequel. In fact, this announcement came just two weeks after Thanksgiving’s release. However, it has now been three years since the release of the holiday slasher and fans are wondering if it is still in the works.

When questioned in mid-2026 about the continuation of his holiday hit, Roth stated common obstacles currently stand in the way. For instance, many of the cast members he plans to return to the small town of Plymouth are currently busy with other commitments. He told Polygon earlier this year in an interview;
“It’s just really a question of trying to figure out how we can shoot this movie and scheduling everybody, because everybody’s just so busy,”

However, he has confirmed the film will be a sequel, not a prequel. He also told the website that the script is pretty much finished. And while he aims to keep the budget of filming low, Roth plans to increase the number of kills and level of action in the sequel.
Let us know at iHorror; Do you plan on watching Eli Roth’s Thanksgiving this Turkey Day? Share with us your favorite scenes in the comments!

