Scroll through r/malefashionadvice long enough and you’ll notice something. The same question comes up every few months: “What’s one clothing purchase you never regretted?” And the same answers keep bubbling to the top — upvoted by thousands of guys who’ve actually lived with the stuff.
I’ve been fitting men in clothes for close to two decades now. I ran a custom suit company before Real Men Real Style became what it is. So when I see thousands of regular guys converging on the same handful of items, I pay attention — because it lines up almost exactly with what I tell my own readers.
Here’s the deal. This post is the greatest hits. Fifteen wardrobe investments that Reddit’s menswear community — and yours truly — say you’ll never regret. Fewer pieces. Better pieces. A wardrobe that actually works.
Key Takeaways
- Buy fewer things, but spend more per item. It’s cheaper in the long run.
- Fit beats brand. A $200 blazer tailored well beats an $800 blazer that hangs like a curtain.
- Leather, wool, and cotton — the classics — outlast everything trendy.
- Shoes and outerwear are where cheap really hurts you. Don’t skimp there.
- If a piece can’t work with three other things in your closet, put it back.
Why “Investment” Doesn’t Mean “Expensive”
Look, I don’t want you thinking “investment piece” means dropping four figures on a jacket. It doesn’t. An investment piece is anything you’ll wear a hundred times, that ages instead of falling apart, and that doesn’t scream any particular year of fashion.
Cost-per-wear is the metric that matters. A $300 pair of boots you wear 500 times costs you 60 cents a wear. A $60 pair you replace every year costs you the same — except you look worse the whole time. And you’re constantly shopping. Which, if you’re anything like me, you don’t have time for.
1. A Pair of Well-Made Leather Boots
This is the #1 answer on Reddit, hands down. Guys post pictures of their Red Wing Iron Rangers or Allen Edmonds Higgins Mills five and ten years in, and the boots look better than the day they bought them.
Get a Goodyear-welted boot. That means the sole can be replaced instead of tossed. Red Wing, Allen Edmonds, Thursday Boot Company if you want an entry price point that punches above its weight. Brown or a nice oxblood beats black for versatility — you can wear brown boots with jeans, chinos, and even most casual suits.
I’ve got a pair of Allen Edmonds I bought before my youngest was born. They’ve been resoled once. They’ll outlive the truck I drive.
2. A Solid Navy Blazer
If a man came to me and said “I have $400 and one thing to buy,” I’d tell him navy blazer. Every time.
A navy blazer works with gray trousers, tan chinos, dark denim, white shirts, blue shirts, chambray shirts — you get the picture. Wear it to a wedding. Wear it to a job interview. Wear it to dinner where you don’t know the dress code. It never looks wrong.
Spier & Mackay makes a fantastic one under $400. Suitsupply if you want to spend a bit more. And whatever you buy — get it tailored. Non-negotiable.
3. A White Oxford-Cloth Button-Down (OCBD)
Reddit loves the OCBD, and Reddit is right. Charles Tyrwhitt, Brooks Brothers, Kamakura if you want to go up a level. This is the shirt you wear under a blazer, tucked into chinos, untucked with jeans, or half-tucked on a Saturday.
Buy two. One white, one light blue. That’s most of your shirt problems solved for the next three years.
4. Dark, Raw or Selvedge Denim
The guys on r/malefashionadvice will happily debate raw denim for 400 comments. But everyone agrees on the principle: dark, well-fitting jeans in a straight or slim-straight cut are the most versatile pants you can own.
Levi’s 501s are fine. Unbranded (UB) makes affordable selvedge. 3sixteen and Iron Heart if you want to go deep. Whatever you pick — dark wash, no distressing, no rips, no whiskering paid for at the factory.
5. A Real Leather Belt (Not the Reversible Junk)
The reversible black-and-brown belt from the mall? Throw it out. Seriously.
A real belt is made from a single strip of leather, not glued layers. It’ll cost you $80 to $150. It’ll last a decade. Brands like Anson Belt, Filson, Tanner Goods, or a solid one from Allen Edmonds. Match your belt to your shoes — brown belt, brown shoes; black belt, black shoes — and you’ve solved 80% of the “does this look right?” question.
6. Gray Wool Trousers
Here’s a piece Reddit under-recommends and I over-recommend. Gray wool trousers are the missing link between a suit and jeans. You can wear them with your navy blazer for a business look, or with a sweater and boots for a smarter casual look.
Charcoal or medium gray. Flat front. Wool or wool-blend so they hold a crease. Get them hemmed properly — no break or a slight break, not the puddle-of-fabric look I still see on grown men at church.
7. A Camel or Charcoal Overcoat
If you live anywhere it gets cold — and I live in Wisconsin, so believe me, I know cold — a proper wool overcoat is one of those things you buy once and use for twenty winters. A knee-length wool topcoat over a suit or a sweater instantly makes you look like a grown man instead of a guy in a puffer with a college logo.
Camel is dressy but works with almost everything. Charcoal is more forgiving on dirt and city grime. Brooks Brothers, Spier & Mackay, or if you can find a vintage Aquascutum or Burberry at a thrift store — grab it.
8. Merino Wool Sweaters
Cotton sweaters pill and stretch. Cashmere is nice but delicate. Merino wool is the sweet spot — warm, wrinkle-resistant, doesn’t smell after wear, holds its shape for years.
Get a navy crewneck, a charcoal V-neck, and maybe an oatmeal or burgundy for variety. Uniqlo makes a shockingly good extra-fine merino for under $60. Spend more if you want, but you don’t have to.
9. A Watch You’ll Wear Every Day
The wristwatch is one of the few pieces of jewelry a man gets to wear. Reddit will fight about brands until the sun burns out — but the actual advice is simple: pick one watch, wear it every day, and take care of it.
You’ve got options at every budget:
- Under $200: Seiko 5, Timex Weekender, Casio F-91W (the “James Bond in Bulgaria” watch)
- $200–$800: Seiko Alpinist, Hamilton Khaki Field, Tissot Le Locle
- $800 and up: Omega, Grand Seiko, Tudor, Rolex if you’ve got it
I’ll be honest — I wear a fairly simple field watch most days. When I was a Marine, we didn’t wear gold-plated anything on our wrists, and the habit stuck.
10. A White Leather Sneaker
This is the shoe that fills the gap between boot and dress shoe. Clean, minimal, white leather sneakers — not chunky trainers, not running shoes with the logo the size of your fist.
Common Projects if you want the icon. Beckett Simonon and Oliver Cabell for a fraction of the price. Adidas Stan Smiths for the budget play. Wear them with jeans, chinos, even a casual suit. Just keep them clean — a scuffed white sneaker looks worse than no white sneaker.
11. A Genuine Trench or Rain Coat
A good trench coat isn’t just spy-movie stuff. It’s the answer to “what do I wear over a suit when it’s 50 degrees and raining?” It’s the answer to “how do I not look like a slob at the airport?”
Khaki or navy. Below the knee, or right at it. Cotton gabardine so it actually sheds rain. Brooks Brothers, Sanyo, or hunt for vintage. Throw one on and suddenly the outfit underneath looks like you planned it.
12. Merino or Wool Dress Socks
Sounds silly on a list of “investments,” but hear me out. Cotton dress socks slide down your ankle, wear through at the heel in three months, and look like sweaty gym socks by lunchtime. Merino wool dress socks last for years, regulate temperature, and don’t stink.
Darn Tough, Boardroom Socks, Smartwool. Spend the $18 a pair. Your feet will write me a thank-you note.
13. A Well-Fitting T-Shirt (Yes, Really)
You’d think a T-shirt wouldn’t make an “investment” list. But go read the Reddit threads — guys rave about their heavyweight cotton tees the way they rave about their boots.
The difference between a $6 Hanes and a $40 Buck Mason or 3sixteen or Uniqlo Supima tee is night and day. The heavier weight cotton drapes better. The neckline holds its shape. The sleeves hit at the right spot on your bicep instead of flapping around like a flag. You’ll wear it twice a week. Buy three in white, gray, and navy.
14. A Real Leather Wallet or Cardholder
Your wallet is the accessory you touch more often than anything else you own. And most guys are carrying around a nylon bifold from the airport gift shop that’s older than their marriage.
Bellroy, Tanner Goods, Saddleback Leather, or a Filson bifold. Full-grain leather. It’ll develop a patina — that beautiful darkening and softening — over years of use. Consider it a small daily luxury. Mine has three cards, some cash, and nothing else. You do not need to carry every membership card you’ve ever owned, my friend.
15. A Charcoal or Navy Suit — Made to Measure
We end where the Reddit threads always end: with the suit. And here’s my hard take, from a guy who used to sell them for a living — buy one really good suit before you buy three mediocre ones.
Charcoal or navy. Wool. Two-button. Notch lapel. Half-canvas construction at minimum (full canvas if the budget allows). Get it made to measure if you can — Spier & Mackay, Indochino, or a local tailor.
A great suit that fits you is the single most transformative piece of clothing a man can own. I’ve watched clients walk out of a fitting looking five years younger and ten IQ points smarter. Not exaggerating.
Common Mistakes Guys Make Building an “Investment” Wardrobe
I’ve watched a lot of men try to do this and screw it up in the same ways. Here are the traps.
Buying the “forever piece” before the everyday pieces
You don’t need a $2,000 sport coat before you own a decent belt and three shirts that fit. Fill your gaps first, then upgrade.
Chasing trends dressed up as classics
That crazy-narrow lapel from 2015? That cropped, boxy suit jacket from 2019? Both sold as “modern classics.” Both look dated now. Real classics don’t have a year attached to them.
Ignoring fit because the brand is good
I’ll say this until I’m blue in the face — a Zara jacket that fits you beats a Tom Ford jacket that doesn’t. Every time. Find a tailor. Use them.
Buying black when brown would work harder
Black shoes and belts are for suits and formal events. Brown works with jeans, chinos, gray trousers, and most suits. If you’re buying one — buy brown.
Forgetting maintenance
A $400 pair of boots without shoe trees, polish, and the occasional resole becomes a $400 pair of ruined boots. Same for suits (dry clean sparingly, brush often), sweaters (fold, don’t hang), and leather anything (condition twice a year).
My Bottom-Line Recommendation
If you’re starting from zero and want the shortest path to a wardrobe you won’t regret, here’s the order I’d buy things in:
- Get a tailor first. Then buy the following.
- Navy blazer (Spier & Mackay) + gray wool trousers — instant business or business-casual outfit.
- Two OCBDs, one white one blue (Charles Tyrwhitt or Brooks Brothers).
- Brown Goodyear-welted boots (Thursday Boot Co. or Allen Edmonds).
- Dark denim that fits (Levi’s, Unbranded, or 3sixteen).
- A charcoal or navy made-to-measure suit when you can swing it.
- A wool overcoat before your first real winter.
Everything else on the list — the watch, the wallet, the sneakers, the sweaters — fills in over the next two or three years. You don’t buy it all at once. That’s the whole point. You buy one great thing, wear it out, love it, and then add the next one.
FAQ
How much should I spend on an “investment” wardrobe piece?
There’s no fixed number. The rule I use: divide the price by the number of times you’ll realistically wear it in a year. If that’s under $2, it’s a good buy. Boots you wear 200 times a year at $300? Six bucks a wear the first year, and it goes down every year after.
Is it worth buying used or thrifted investment pieces?
Absolutely. Some of the best pieces I’ve ever owned came off eBay, Grailed, or a thrift shop. Brooks Brothers suits, Aquascutum trenches, Alden shoes — the resale market is packed with quality gear at a fraction of retail. Just check the fit and condition carefully, and budget for tailoring.
What’s one thing I should NOT buy as an “investment”?
Ties. I know that’s ironic coming from me. But ties change with trends more than most guys admit — widths shift, textures come and go — and you’ll get bored of them long before they wear out. Buy nice ties, but don’t drop a fortune on a “forever” tie. Same goes for anything with heavy logos or extreme cuts.
How do I know if something will last?
Look at the construction. Are seams double-stitched? Is the leather full-grain (not “genuine leather” — that’s the second-worst grade)? Is the jacket canvassed or fused? Are the buttons real horn or shell, or plastic? Read the label. Read the reviews. And when in doubt, ask a menswear forum — those guys will tell you the truth, even if it’s brutal.
Should I buy one great suit or several cheap ones?
One great one. Every time. A man in a well-fitting charcoal suit that cost him $900 looks better than a man in three baggy $300 suits — and he’ll get another decade out of it.
Closing Thoughts
Here’s the thing I want you to take away, gentlemen. Building a great wardrobe isn’t about buying more. It’s about buying right, wearing it hard, taking care of it, and letting it become part of who you are.
The truck I drive is a 1997 Chevy Silverado I bought new in Cedar Rapids the same year I joined the Marines. It’s hit two deer. It still runs. That’s what a real investment looks like — something that shows up, does the job, and gets better as it ages. Your wardrobe can do the same thing. It just takes patience and a little bit of taste.
Buy less. Buy better. Wear it out. And when you find that one perfect brown boot or that navy blazer that fits like it was drawn on you — hang on to it. Guys like us don’t need much. We just need the right stuff.
The post 15 Wardrobe Investments Men Never Regret — According to Thousands of Reddit Users appeared first on Real Men Real Style.