Think of your favorite movie character of all time. There is a good chance that the actor who ended up playing that part is not the first actor the studio approached. See for yourself by taking a look at this list of celebrities who decided to pass on a movie role that would turn out to make cinematic history.
Will Smith (Neo In The Matrix)
It is actually pretty easy for us to picture what the Matrix movies might have been like with Will Smith as Neo. However, the Academy Award winner seems to believe that Keanu Reeves was the better choice to play the chosen one in the mind-bending, dystopian sci-fi movie classic, claiming in a video on his YouTube channel that he would have “ruined it.”
Jodie Foster (Princess Leia in Star Wars)
Fresh off her Academy Award-nominated breakthrough role in 1976’s Taxi Driver, a teenage Jodie Foster was offered the chance to be a part of the Star Wars movies as Princess Leia Organa. As she revealed to Jimmy Fallon on The Tonight Show, the two-time Oscar winner had a contractual obligation to an unnamed Disney movie, allowing Carrie Fisher to win the role.
Tom Hanks (Jerry Maguire In Jerry Maguire)
Tom Hanks was on top of the world with two Oscar wins (for Philadelphia and Forrest Gump) when he was offered to play a sports agent down on his luck in Jerry Maguire. He ended up passing on the eponymous role from Cameron Crowe’s 1996 dramedy and later told Access Hollywood (via FandomWire), “I think you look at it now and it couldn’t have been anybody other than Tom Cruise,” who would receive a nod from the Academy for his performance.
Leonardo DiCaprio (Patrick Bateman In American Psycho)
Christian Bale once told GQ that every one of his roles was first offered to Leonardo DiCaprio and one confirmed example is Patrick Bateman in 2000’s American Psycho. The future Oscar winner told The Morning Call that he passed on playing the sadistic yuppie because he felt the script “didn’t mean anything in the end,” but rumor has it Bale’s stepmom, Gloria Steinem, convinced DiCaprio that it would be bad for his post-Titanic, romantic heartthrob reputation at the time.
Jean-Claude Van Damme (The Predator In Predator)
The titular terrifying alien enemy from 1987’s Predator looked a lot different when Jean-Claude Van Damme was still in the role, according to THR‘s oral history. The Belgian actor star actually shot some footage in the original insect-like suit before deciding he would rather not be hidden in his own movie, leading to a redesign of the costume and the casting of 7’2″ Kevin Peter Hall.
Jack Nicholson (Michael Corleone In The Godfather)
While we cannot imagine anyone other than Al Pacino as Michael Corleone, Jack Nicholson probably would have been great in the Godfather movies. However, the three-time Oscar winner refused the offer, explaining to Movieline in 2004 (via ScreenRant) that he believed “Italians should play Italians.”
John Travolta (Forrest Gump In Forrest Gump)
When speaking with MTV News (via Collider), John Travolta revealed that he had no regrets about turning down the title role of the Best Picture Oscar winner Forrest Gump and it is no wonder why. Not only did Tom Hanks embody the role to Oscar-winning acclaim but Travolta found career-rejuvenating success with Pulp Fiction in 1994 instead.
Burt Reynolds (James Bond In Live And Let Die)
In 2015, Burt Reynolds told USA Today that, when approached to be Sean Connery’s replacement in the James Bond films, he believed the public would not accept a 007 with an American accent. However, he would later come to believe that, “It was a stupid thing to say. I could’ve done it and I could’ve done it well.”
Eddie Murphy (Winston Zeddemore In Ghostbusters)
While appearing on The Tonight Show in 2019, Eddie Murphy was asked by Jimmy Fallon if it is true that he passed on playing Winston Zeddemore in Ghostbusters. The comedian confirmed that it was true but added that it allowed him the opportunity to lead an even bigger hit from 1984: Beverly Hills Cop.
John Lithgow (Seth Brundle In The Fly)
Jeff Goldblum’s iconic role from David Cronenberg’s 1986 remake of The Fly was previously offered to John Lithgow, who told IndieWire that he said no, not wanting to play “something so grotesque.” Having witnessed Seth Brundle’s transformation into a half-human, half-insect in the intense body horror movie, we cannot say we blame him.
Tom Selleck (Indiana Jones In Raiders Of The Lost Ark)
Having already worked with Harrison Ford three times before, George Lucas was reluctant to cast the Han Solo actor as Indiana Jones, opening up the opportunity for a rotation of actors, including Tom Selleck. As he recalled on Today, the actor was forced to pass on 1981’s Raiders of the Lost Ark, due to his commitment to the CBS crime drama, Magnum P.I.
Christopher Lee (Dr. Loomis In Halloween)
While already a horror movie icon at the time for his acclaimed portrayal of Dracula and role in 1973’s The Wicker Man, Christopher Lee could have added one of the all-time best horror movies, 1978’s Halloween, to his resume. According to The Digital Fix, he would come to regret the decision to pass on the role of Michael Myers’ psychiatrist, Dr. Sam Loomis, who was immortalized by Donald Pleasance instead.
Christina Applegate (Elle Woods In Legally Blonde)
Before Reese Witherspoon made Elle Woods an icon among fictional lawyers in Legally Blonde and among fictional politicians in the sequel, Legally Blonde 2: Red, White & Blonde, the role was offered to Christina Applegate. The former Married… with Children star later explained to Entertainment Tonight that she was afraid of repeating the ditzy blonde but jokes it was a “stupid move.”
Emily Blunt (Black Widow In Iron Man 2)
Scarlett Johansson was perfect as Natasha Romanoff but Emily Blunt would have made a killing as the Avenger also called Black Widow. The English actor explained to Howard Stern that she could not originate the role for the MCU in 2010’s Iron Man 2 because she was contractually obligated to appear in that year’s adaptation of Gulliver’s Travels.
Emma Watson (Mia In La La Land)
Playing Mia in 2016’s La La Land earned Emma Stone her first Oscar win but the role of the aspiring actor had originally gone to another Emma: Emma Watson. The Harry Potter movies star said in a SiriusXM Town Hall interview (via Us Weekly) that her commitment to Beauty and the Beast and the hard work required to star in the musical led her to pull out.
Gwyneth Paltrow (Rollergirl In Boogie Nights)
Heather Graham made her mainstream breakthrough in 1998’s Boogie Nights as “Rollergirl” – a role that was previously offered to Gwyneth Paltrow. The future Oscar winner told Howard Stern (via Us Weekly) that she passed because she feared the role, which required her to completely disrobe and simulate lewd acts on camera, would “kill” her conservative grandfather.
Jennifer Hudson (Precious In Precious)
Jennifer Hudson had previously said in her memoir, I Got This: How I Changed My Ways And Lost What Weighed Me Down, that she turned down the title role of Precious because she did not want to take a role that involved her weight. The Oscar winner later retracted that statement when speaking to The Huffington Post, explaining that Was not interested in what the role, which ultimately went to Gabourey Sibide, would have required her to do at that point in her career.
Matt Damon (Jake Sully In Avatar)
Sam Worthington became a household name when he led James Cameron’s astonishingly successful sci-fi epic, Avatar, as Jake Sully – a role previously offered to Matt Damon. The Oscar winner once joked to Access Hollywood that not participating in the 2009 film cost the movie “a lot.”
Ian McKellan (Albus Dumbledore In Harry Potter And The Prisoner Of Azkaban)
The Lord of the Rings movies‘ Gandalf actor, Sir Ian McKellan, could have added another famous wizard to his resume and become the Harry Potter franchise’s new Albus Dumbledore. Instead, the part went to Michael Gambon after, as he told BBC News, McKellan turned it down because he couldn’t “take over the part from an actor who I’d known didn’t approve of me,” referring to the late Richard Harris who was a vocal critic of the actor.
Drew Barrymore (Sidney Prescott In Scream)
Given Drew Barrymore’s A-list status in 1996, audiences assumed that she was the lead of Wes Craven’s Scream, which could have been the case, as she confirmed on Hot Ones. However, she requested to be killed off in the beginning as Casey Becker, knowing it would shock the audience, paving the way for Neve Campbell to become a Scream Queen in the role of Sidney Prescott.
Angela Bassett (Leticia Musgrove In Monster’s Ball)
Halle Berry became the first Black Best Actress Oscar winner for her performance in Monster’s Ball as Leticia Musgrove – a role that was offered to Angela Bassett. According to EW, the Black Panther: Wakanda Forever star felt the part of a Black call girl was too stereotypical.
Sean Connery (Gandalf In The Lord Of The Rings: The Fellowship Of The Ring)
Sir Ian McKellan mentions in an oral history about the Lord of the Rings series for The Independent that an earlier choice to play Gandalf the Grey was Sir Sean Connery. New Line Cinema executive Mark Ordesky notes that the former James Bond actor passed on the role of the wizard simply because he “did not get it.”
Bette Midler (Annie Wilkes In Misery)
Despite having no qualms about playing an actual evil witch in 1993’s Hocus Pocus, Bette Midler did have some reservations about playing Annie Wilkes in Rob Reiner’s adaptation of Stephen King’s Misery from 1990. The actor and singer told Variety that was interested in playing the sadistic nurse because of her violent, unfunny, and irredeemable qualities.
Warren Beatty (Bill In Kill Bill)
In 2003, Quentin Tarantino told BBC that he originally started writing the title role of Kill Bill with Warren Beatty in mind because he wanted to work with him and the Oscar winner was set to play the target of Uma Thurman’s vengeful Bride for a bit. However, after realizing that David Carradine was a better fit, followed by consideration of the time commitment and martial arts training involved, the actor and filmmaker amicably agreed to part ways.
Michelle Pfeiffer (Clarice Starling In The Silence Of The Lambs)
Michelle Pfeiffer once told Today’s Hoda Kotb (via People) that her reasons for passing on roles in the likes of Pretty Woman and Basic Instinct typically had to do with scheduling conflicts. However, she told The New Yorker she passed on playing Clarice Starling (which ultimately went to Jodie Foster) in 1991’s The Silence of the Lambs because the “evil” in the film made her nervous.
Al Pacino (Han Solo In Star Wars)
In his memoir, Sonny Boy, Al Pacino reveals that, before Harrison Ford was cast in Star Wars, he was offered the role of Han Solo. The Oscar winner explains that he could not “make anything out of” George Lucas’ script and chose not to play the pilot of the Millennium Falcon.
Bela Lugosi (The Creature In Frankenstein)
According to the book, The Immortal Count: The Life and Films of Bela Lugosi by Arthur Lennig (via SlashFilm), the star of 1931’s Dracula had the opportunity to play two Universal Monsters in the same year, having also been offered to play The Creature in Frankenstein. However, the actor believed such a role was “beneath him,” paving the way for Boris Karloff to rise up in the ranks of horror royalty as Dr. Victor Frankenstein’s creation.
Haley Lu Richardson (Dani Ardor In Midsommar)
Haley Lu Richardson, known for one of the best M. Night Shyamalan movies, Split, passed on the role of Dani Ardor in Ari Aster’s 2019 sophomore effort, Midsommar. The A24 horror masterpiece was ultimately led by Florence Pugh, whom Richardson told Backstage she has nothing but praise for, despite not yet having the courage to watch the movie.
Julia Roberts (Annie Reed In Sleepless In Seattle)
The two most prestigious queens of the rom-com genre would have to be Julia Roberts and Meg Ryan but only one could play Annie Reed in Sleepless in Seattle. Roberts told InStyle (via ABC News) that she was offered the part but could not do it, adding that Ryan and Tom Hanks “are just such a jewel of a fit in that.”
Jamie Lee Curtis (Regan MacNeil In The Exorcist)
Jamie Lee Curtis became horror royalty with her feature film debut in 1978’s Halloween but her reign could have begun earlier if not for one thing: her mother, Janet Leigh. Curtis told EW that, when she was asked to audition for Regan MacNeil in 1973’s The Exorcist (which would go to Linda Blair), the Psycho star spoke on the then-13-year-old’s behalf and refused the offer.
Lee Marvin (Quint In Jaws)
Robert Shaw’s performance as Quint in Jaws is nearly as famous as the man-eating shark itself but the English actor was actually not Steven Spielberg’s first choice. The filmmaker told Vanity Fair that he previously approached Lee Marvin but the Dirty Dozen star was not interested.
Sarah Michelle Gellar (Amber In Clueless)
Elisa Donovan’s character in Clueless, Amber, very nearly went to the future star of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Sarah Michelle Gellar. Adam Schroeder, the co-producer of the 1995 high school movie classic, told Vanity Fair that the actor’s commitment to the soap opera All My Children at the time forced her to recede from consideration.