More than a decade later, Emily Ratajkowski‘s appearance on iCarly is still so wonderful.
Just ask series co-stars Jerry Trainor (Spencer) and Nathan Kress (Freddie) who recently took a trip down memory lane, more specifically, to the original show’s third season. ICYMI, Emily played the girlfriend of fan-favorite Gibby (played by Noah Munck) for two episodes back in 2009.
As for what Nathan and Jerry—who alongside Miranda Gosgrove, Laci Mosley and Jaiyden Triplett star in the show’s Paramount+ revival—would have to say about her part? Well, they shared just how they feel.
“It was just hilarious,” Jerry said in an exclusive interview with E! News’ Francesca Amiker. “Her and Gibby, we would all just be like, ‘Wait you two…together…what? How is this even working?'”
“But it worked!” Nathan added. “I’ll be darned, it worked.”
And for fans wondering if Emily would ever be open to returning to the series, there’s a chance that somehow, we’re gonna get there.
“I heard she wants to come back on the show,” Jerry noted. “That’s what I heard!”