Andy Cohen said if Lisa Rinna did bring a second envelope containing receipts from Kathy Hilton’s alleged “psychotic break” in Colorado, she never showed them during the “Real Housewives of Beverly Hills” reunion.
“She had what were her Aspen receipts that we never saw – that I never saw. We didn’t get to them, we didn’t cut them out of the show, she never handed them over during the show, so that is the tale of Rinna’s receipts,” Cohen, 54, said on Wednesday’s episode of his SiriusXM show “Andy Cohen Live.”
Earlier this week, Cohen told fans that Rinna, 59, brought one envelope with receipts relating to her Elton John Aids Foundation feud with Sutton Stracke but that scene was cut because “enough is enough” with the year-long disagreement.
Rinna then took to Instagram to say she in fact had two envelopes with one containing text messages she sent to various people when Kathy Hilton was having her alleged meltdown during the infamous cast trip to Aspen.
“I text Rinna, I go, ‘I said on the radio today that your receipts were about the Elton John Aids thing is that what they were? Were there also Aspen receipts?’” Cohen said he asked her.
The “Watch What Happens Live” host then explained that Rinna told him what she revealed on Tuesday – that she brought eight printed pages of text messages she sent to Erika Jayne and a third party friend when she was alone with Hilton during her alleged meltdown.
“She said ‘that was kind of my corroboration that I sent those texts that night,’ and that’s what that was, and she never entered them to the court for consideration. We never got to them,” Cohen said, referring to the reunion.
Cohen explained that he’s addressing the envelopes again, because he went on social media and saw fans saying “Rinna is calling you a liar” over his one envelope claim.
“This is me saying I believe both of these situations to be true,” he concluded.
Rinna has kept quiet on Cohen’s update of the receipts.