Following the discovery of Chantal, the Search Party crew moves quickly to bury Keith’s body, which they put in a loud zebra-stripped suitcase. As they return to their lives in the city, Dory and company convince Chantal—who is oblivious to the murder—to lie about her whereabouts, so they aren’t connected to Montreal in any way.
While Dory, Drew, Elliott and Portia attempt to act normal, they each struggle to move on. Specifically, Dory finds herself connecting with Keith’s ex-wife, Portia joins a play about the Manson family murders, Elliott’s body becomes covered in hives and Drew attempts a relocation to China.
The drama worsens when Dory and Drew’s neighbor April (Phoebe Tyers) blackmails the group, having recorded their murder confession thanks to a paper-thin apartment wall. She demands $60,000 for her silence.